So, with all the hype surrounding the release of the ‘New iPad’ (no new name apparently), you may be wondering if you should take the plunge or stick with your old iPad 2. Here’s my view:
First off, if you don’t own an iPad, or have the original version, I’d go for it. It’s certainly a fine piece of technology and a vast upgrade over the iPad 1.
On the other hand, I don’t see the new unit being worth purchasing if you’ve already invested in an iPad 2 — unless you require it for testing purposes as we who develop for the iOS platform do. The improvements to the screen are very nice; but most people won’t really miss them should they just retain their iPad 2.
Camera improvements? Who really uses the camera on the iPad anyway? The only time I do is for video conferencing; and I am not as concerned about resolution as I am in performance, which would be decreased should hi-rez be utilized in FaceTime. The front-facing camera hasn’t been improved anyway; so that’s a non-issue.
The faster chip is nice… but most people wouldn’t miss it unless they had the units side-by-side to compare. For the majority of applications people use, the impact is going to be next to diddly-squat.
LTE? Well that’s great in theory; however, wireless network speeds in Canada at least are poor and inconsistent. Beyond that, associated data plans are ridiculously expensive; and most people use their iPads on Wifi as a result. So, again, not a big deal.
I really feel that subsequent to Steve Jobs’ death, Apple has delivered two lacklustre products in a row with the iPhone 4s and the ‘New iPad’. Siri? Really? That was available on the app store before Apple acquired the company that designed it. Sure they improved the product; but does an app justify a purchase decision for a new phone?
The improved camera on the iPhone 4s is certainly a better fit, given the number of people who use it on that platform… but is it enough to warrant an upgrade? If you had to expend $800 for a new phone (as I do, given my refusal to be locked into contracts thanks very much) would you consider that a worthwhile investment, given the minor improvements the 4s represents? I don’t, and will be waiting for the iPhone 5, which will hopefully bring a lot more in terms of innovation to the table.
I don’t expect incremental improvement from you Apple; that’s not what I pay a premium price for. I want revolutionary, not evolutionary. It’s what people expect of you… please deliver.
